Genre: fluff, smut
Word Count: 4592
Summary: Sehun and Kai both love Kyungsoo and she loves them too. But can she choose between her two boys when they confess to her at the same time? Or is there another solution?
originally posted here
The first time Kyungsoo met Sehun and Kai, they had been new students and lost. She had stumbled across them on her way to class and their expressions had been so adorable, she couldn’t resist helping them at the risk of being late to her own class.
Needless to say, after that, the two boys were constantly by her side.
“Noona, Noona, Noona! What are you doing after school today? Want to go hang out with me and Sehun?” Kai looked at Kyungsoo from across the cafeteria table.
“I’m sorry, but I have choir practice today. Maybe another time.”
Kai pouted, causing Kyungsoo to chuckle. “Aww, don’t be sad. I’ll hang out with you two another day.”
“But Noona, we want to hang out with you now.”
Kyungsoo laughed. “You two are so cute. How about this weekend? We’ll go see a movie.”
The movie date was uneventful, at least for Kyungsoo. But what she hadn’t noticed was that Kai and Sehun were constantly vying for her attention, fighting over who got to do what.
“Noona, here’s your ticket. I bought it for you.” Sehun preened as he handed her the ticket.
“Noona, what snacks do you want? I’ll buy them for you.” Kai smiled as he waited patiently for Kyungsoo’s response. He quickly bought them after she mentioned wanting nachos.
“Here, let me get the door for you.”
“No, let me.”
Both Kai and Sehun held open the double doors leading into the theater. Kyungsoo smiled and walked inside, the two following close on her tail. She sat between them during the movie and was oblivious to the two boys fighting for the back of her chair. In the end, no one rested their arm there; however, Kai and Sehun each held her hand during the movie when a particularly frightening scene came up.
Kyungsoo had been clenching the armrests tightly until she felt a warm grip holding her hand tightly.
“If you’re scared, noona, just squeeze my hand tight.”
“You can squeeze my hand too, noona.”
Kyungsoo smiled gratefully and held their hands tightly.
She thought her dongsaengs were sweet for taking care of her like that for their movie date even though she was their noona and should be taking care of them. She enjoyed the rest of the movie, the warmth from the two boys washing over her and protecting her from the scary moments in the movie.
Sehun and Kai had instantly fallen in love with Kyungsoo the first time they saw her. She was a petite brunette with adorable eyes, heart shaped lips, and round cheeks. The feelings had deepened the more time they spent in her company. She was caring and sweet but also authoritative when needed. She didn’t take anyone’s crap but sometimes melted against really cute things. Kai and Sehun liked to take advantage of her love for cute things, bombarding her at random times with aegyo and watching her cheeks flush.
Being best friends, they supported each other when they found out their mutual feelings for Kyungsoo and yet, loved to compete against one another. They were constantly vying for Kyungsoo’s attention, trying to be the nicer gentleman to her. It would’ve been better if they had been able to have some alone time with Kyungsoo to show her their charm, but as they were constantly together, it became a joint effort.
“Noona, I like you.”
Kyungsoo stared at the two boys standing before her, each holding a single rose in front of her. She had never suspected that her two precious dongsaengs would have such feelings for her. She’d be lying if she hadn’t thought about having a relationship with either one, but having them confess at the same time in the same way was overwhelming.
“Um…thank you but…”
Sehun and Kai wore matching pouts as they watched Kyungsoo fumble for a kind of response. They shared a look before giving an encouraging smile to Kyungsoo.
“Noona, if you need some time, we’ll give it to you. We don’t want you to feel bad or anything.”
“Don’t worry about us, worry about yourself. We’ll give you all the time you want.”
Kai and Sehun walked over towards Kyungsoo, gently putting the roses in her hand. They leaned down and each pressed a kiss on her cheek before walking away.
Kyungsoo stood there, cheeks flushed and mind whirling with thoughts.
Kyungsoo collapsed on the table, head buried in her arms. “Guys, I have a problem.”
“If it has anything to do with Kai and Sehun liking you, then it’s nothing new.”
“Wait, what?!?!?! You guys knew?” Kyungsoo stared at her friends in disbelief. “Why didn’t you tell me?”
“Wasn’t it obvious?” Baekhyun rolled her eyes. “Those two were hanging around you like all the time like little puppies. It was a bit disgusting, seeing them panting after you. I’m surprised you never got hit by their drool.”
“Oh lay off, Baekhyun. You know Kyungsoo has problems noticing when anyone likes her.” Luhan gently hit the back of Baekhyun’s head as she took a seat. “Besides, don’t you have that same issue too?”
“What are you talking about?” Baekhyun looked at Luhan confused.
Luhan shook her head. “Never mind. It’s way over your head.”
She shared a knowing look with Kyungsoo. They looked over the top of Baekhyun’s head at the guy who was staring at Baekhyun’s back with such longing in his eyes. The two giggled before Luhan leveled Kyungsoo with a look.
“So what’s the issue? Did the two finally confess to you?”
“Yeah, and I don’t know what to do.” Kyungsoo sighed, running her hands through her hair in frustration. “I mean I have thought about what it was like to go out with either one. They’re both so hot and very sweet. Any girl would be lucky to date them but for both of them to like me and to confess at the same time, it’s just…”
“A little overwhelming?” Joonmyun smiled as she sat down next to Kyungsoo. She rubbed a gentle hand over Kyungsoo’s back.
Kyungsoo pouted, nodding her head.
“Want to come over later and we’ll talk it over?”
“Yes.” Kyungsoo beamed and hugged her best friend.
“Hey, can I come over too?” Baekhyun turned her puppy eyes towards Joonmyun.
Joonmyun chuckled. “Sorry, but I don’t have time to supervise you as you run around my closet. Plus don’t you have practice after school?”
“I could say the same for you.” Baekhyun arched a brow.
“A friend needs help. Besides, we’re allowed to skip practice once in a while.” Joonmyun smiled as Baekhyun gaped.
“You are so unfair, Joonmyun. Whenever I want to skip, you won’t let me. But for Kyungsoo, you’re willing to skip.”
Joonmyun smiled brightly. “That’s ‘cause she’s my best friend.”
Joonmyun wrapped her arms around Kyungsoo beaming brightly. Kyungsoo just smiled at Baekhyun who frowned.
“So unfair…never would’ve expected this of Ms. Proper.”
Luhan laughed. “Oh Baekhyun, do you really believe that?”
“No. But I’m allowed to complain, can’t I?”
“A diva like you, yeah.” Luhan laughed, ducking when Baekhyun tried to hit her.
Kyungsoo followed Joonmyun home where she instantly made herself comfortable in one of Joonmyun’s chairs in her room.
“So want to talk about it?”
Kyungsoo sighed. “I have no idea what to do. They said they’d give me time but how much time? I mean I’ve thought about dating one of them before, what it would be like, but I never expected both of them to like me but then again, I can’t even decide between the two of them. They’re both so similar and yet different. They have their good points and bad points because really, everyone has their flaws. But how do I know which one I should choose? I don’t want to hurt them but won’t someone get hurt if I choose one over the other?”
“You could just not choose one.”
“And hurt them both? I can’t do that. I love my two dongsaengs but what to do? I don’t think I’ve ever dealt with something like this before.” Kyungsoo ran a hand through her hair.
“Well just try going on a date with each of them and see how you feel. You can’t make a good decision without exploring all the possiblities.” Joonmyun smiled as she gently patted Kyungsoo’s back. “Now want to gorge on some snacks to forget this whole experience for now? You know how ice cream always cheers you up.”
Kyungsoo smiled. “As long as you have my favorite flavor.”
“Why wouldn’t I?” Joonmyun headed over to the mini fridge, opening it and grabbing a tiny pint of Kyungsoo’s favorite ice cream.
“You’re the best, Joonmyun.”
“Of course.” Joonmyun beamed. “Now what do you want to watch?”
Kyungsoo walked into school and was instantly met by Sehun and Kai whispering amongst themselves by her locker. Kai spotted her first and quickly cut their conversation short.
“Noona, how are you doing today?”
“Kai…Sehun…” Kyungsoo gave them a wiry smile. “I’m doing okay if a bit overwhelmed again.”
Kai and Sehun looked shocked as Kyungsoo’s words sunk in. She laughed and grabbed the back of their shirts when they tried to move away. “It’s alright but I do need to talk to you.”
“Okay.” The two followed Kyungsoo to a private spot, away from prying eyes and ears.
Kyungsoo took a deep breath before looking at her two dongsaengs. “I like you both, you’re precious to me but…I can’t choose between you two.”
“Do you…would you like to go on a date with us?”
“With you two? At the same time?”
“No, no, no, uh one at a time. We promise we won’t make this hard on you. But give us each a chance to win you over. I know we’re always together but we both really like you and just uh…” Kai awkwardly scratched the back of his neck. “Sorry if I’m not making much sense. This is a first for us so we’re not really sure what to do.”
Kyungsoo blushed. “It’s fine. Why don’t we have our dates this weekend? On Friday and Saturday night. I’ll let you choose who’ll go first. But pick me up at 7PM, okay?”
She leaned up and kissed each of their cheeks before heading to class.
There was a knock on the door right at 7PM. Kyungsoo hurried to the door and found Sehun standing before her. He was dressed casually in skinny jeans and a tank. He held out the single rose for her.
Kyungsoo gave a small smile as she accepted it. “Thanks Sehun. So shall we go?”
“Sure.” Sehun waited for Kyungsoo to grab her things and lock up before shyly taking her hand. They walked towards the local arcade where they ate pizza and played games.
Kyungsoo had a lot of fun, playing video games and sometimes beating Sehun. It was all very casual and relaxing, a good first date in Kyungsoo’s opinion. She gave Sehun a brief kiss goodnight, making both of them blush.
Kai picked her up a few minutes before 7. He also had a rose for her which she accepted, placing it in the same vase as Sehun’s rose from the day before. He walked her towards the car, helping her get in and closing it right after her. They drove to a nice restaurant, not too fancy but not too casual.
Kai was a perfect gentleman, making Kyungsoo blush, seeing how nice and sweet Kai was acting, compared to his normal behavior.
As with Sehun, Kyungsoo gave Kai a brief kiss goodnight, enjoying the heated blush covering Kai’s face. Her own face was red as she quickly shut the door and hurried up to her bedroom.
First thing she did was grab her phone and call Joonmyun.
“What is it, Kyungsoo?”
“I CAN’T CHOOSE!!!!”
Joonmyun laughed. “I’m sure you’ll make a choice. How was the date?”
“The dates were good, they were fine, they were super sweet and made me like them more. How do I choose?!?!?!” Kyungsoo whimpered over the phone.
Joonmyun laughed again. “Oh Kyungsoo, you’re smart. I know you’ll make the right choice. Just give it some time. The answer will come to you.”
Kyungsoo frowned. “Some help you are.”
She hung up the phone and buried her face in pillow.
Sehun and Kai jumped on her when she stepped through the doors. “Noona! Have you made a decision yet?”
“I don’t…I haven’t…why are you guys doing this to me?” Kyungsoo glared at her two dongsaengs. “Why would you put me in this position huh?”
Sehun and Kai looked at each other and then back at the fuming Kyungsoo. “We’re sorry noona, but we just had to tell you how we felt. I’m sorry for all the problems we caused you but we do really like you and well…”
Kai looked at Sehun who nodded. “If you’re really at a loss, we did have a possible suggestion for you to consider if you really can’t decide between us.”
Kyungsoo looked at the two confused. “A suggestion?”
“Yeah but we’ll tell you later. After school…if you want to come over to my house.” Kai gave a small smile.
“Sure. That’s fine with me.”
“Great. We’ll see you later, noona.” The two leaned down, dropping a kiss to Kyungsoo’s cheek before heading off to class.
Kyungsoo made herself comfortable on the couch, Sehun sitting in front of her. Kai went into the kitchen to get them some snacks. He came back a few moments later, setting the tray down on the table and taking a seat next to Sehun.
“So what’s this suggestion of yours?”
“Well uh noona, I’m not sure if you know but me and Sehun are kind of together.”
“Together?” Kyungsoo’s eyebrows rose. “As in boyfriend and boyfriend?”
“Kind of. We’re not really official but we’ve been together for so long it just kind of happened but we keep our distance when one of us is dating.”
“We understand each other.” Sehun smiled, patting Kai’s knee.
Kai just rolled his eyes. “We have a very open relationship even if people don’t really know about us. And well, the thing is both of us really like you and if you can’t choose between us, we were thinking, if you didn’t mind, being in a relationship with both of us.”
“Both of you?” Kyungsoo’s eyes widened.
“I know it might be a lot to ask of you and I’m sure you’re uncomfortable with the idea but –“
“Let’s give it a try.”
“What?” Sehun and Kai stared at Kyungsoo. “You’re…you’re willing to give this a shot?”
Kyungsoo blushed. “Yeah…I’m willing to give it a try.”
Sehun and Kai stared at each other before a wide grin crossed their faces. “Noona!”
The two jumped on top of Kyungsoo, hugging her tight. Someone’s hand grabbed at her ass.
“Hey, hey, hey, who said you could touch?”
Sehun and Kai jumped back in shock.
“Oh my gosh, I’m so sorry, noona. I didn’t – mmph.” Kyungsoo pulled Kai forward for a kiss, shutting him up.
Sehun watched, feeling the temperature rise, as Kyungsoo and Kai made out in front of him. Kai seemed to sense what Sehun was feeling, his hand reaching out to cover Sehun’s crotch. Kyungsoo felt the movement and pulled away to watch Kai caress Sehun’s growing hard-on through his jeans. She felt herself getting warmer as she watched Kai touch Sehun intimately. She must have made a noise for Sehun and Kai turned their attention to her.
With matching grins, the two slowly made their way towards Kyungsoo.
Kyungsoo walked into school the next day with both Kai and Sehun on her arms. Everyone gaped at them as the trio made their way inside.
Joonmyun raised a brow when she saw them together. “Well…I see you’ve made a decision.”
“Kind of.” Kyungsoo smiled as she looked at her two precious dongsaengs. She leaned up and kissed each of them. “I’ll see you two later.”
The two boys grinned at her before heading off to class.
Kyungsoo waited until they were out of sight before turning to her best friend. “Alright, spill.”
“What?” Joonmyun had a look of innocence on her face.
“I know you have something to say so say it.”
“There is nothing to say. I’m just a bit surprised you’re willing to take on two. I thought one on one was more your style.”
Kyungsoo shrugged. “Just thought I’d try something different.”
“Well this is definitely different. Didn’t you say you preferred females, last I checked?”
“I am open to liking and dating anyone. I just happen to be interested in them right now.”
“Alright, but I think it might be a bit too much for you to handle. I mean they’re hard enough to handle in real life. How will you be able to handle them sexually?”
Kyungsoo gaped at her friend’s retreating back. “Why would you say something like that?”
Joonmyun didn’t turn around. “Hurry up or you’ll be late for class.”
Now that she was dating both of her dongsaengs, Kai and Sehun took advantage by spending all their time with Kyungsoo. They would drag her around to places or back to their house for a little fun. Things were still relatively innocent, making out and some intimate touching. A few times, Kyungsoo got a little curious, finding delight in figuring out how to get a moan or groan out of either boy. And the two had fun exploring what gave her pleasure but she was still holding out on sex. She wasn’t a virgin but she was still being cautious as she had never been in a threesome before and wanted to be ready for the experience.
Kai and Sehun were cuddling on the couch, sharing a blanket, as they watched the movie. Kyungsoo watched them from the doorway, having left to get them some more popcorn. She watched them, feeling the affection fill her body. They were home alone for the night so they didn’t have to worry about anything.
Making up her mind, Kyungsoo hurried away.
Kai and Sehun turned towards the sound. Their mouths dropped open as Kyungsoo stood before them, dressed in a lacy black slip that did nothing to hide her body but rather emphasized her breasts and the spot at the apex of her legs.
Kyungsoo began to twist her hands in front of her. She felt uncomfortable with all the silence. “Well…? What do you think?”
Kai cleared his throat. “You should come here.”
Sehun nodded his head in affirmation.
On unsteady legs, Kyungsoo slowly walked towards the two boys. Kai visibly gulped when he noticed the slit in the side, allowing Kyungsoo’s pale leg to peek through. Sehun shifted in his seat as his pants began to tighten uncomfortably.
Kyungsoo stopped right in front of the duo. With clammy hands that Kai hastily wiped on his pants, he pulled Kyungsoo the rest of the way down into his lap. Sehun immediately pressed close, lips attaching to Kyungsoo’s neck.
Kyungsoo tipped her head back as Kai kept a firm grip on her waist, positioning her more comfortably on his lap, fitting her over his growing erection.
Sehun settled behind Kyungsoo, arms wrapping around her waist as his mouth assaulted her neck. Kai watched, enjoying the quiet moans falling from Kyungsoo’s mouth. He gently ran his hands up and down her sides, coming up to cup her breast.
Kyungsoo moaned, head tipping back further onto Sehun’s shoulder as she pushed her breasts forward. Encouraged, Kai gently began to rub his thumbs over her nipples, making them into hard little points. He leaned down and gently swiped his tongue over one over the fabric.
Kyungsoo gave a tiny gasp. Her hands came up to grip into Kai’s hair, holding him in place as he continued to move his tongue over her breast.
Annoyed by the fabric, Kai reached up and, with some help from Sehun, got the top of Kyungsoo’s slip down to her waist, where her beautiful breasts filled his hands. He leaned back down and swiped his tongue over her nipples. He covered her left breast and gently sucked, Kyungsoo’s hands tightening in Kai’s hair.
Her hips began to move as the place between her legs began to dampen. Sehun slipped a hand down, gently pressing against that spot and feeling how wet she was through the fabric. He moved his hand further down to where the slit was and slowly moved his hand back up under the skirt. His hand paused at the top of her thighs, gently running a finger where leg met hip.
Kyungsoo whined, shifting further. Kai moved away from her breasts to cover her mouth with his, tongue slipping inside.
Sehun pulled away and watched Kyungsoo and Kai make out as his fingers continued to tease around Kyungsoo’s entrance. As the two were distracted with each other, he took this chance to take off his clothes, tossing them aside before coming back to sit behind Kyungsoo.
With a firm and gentle grip, he tugged Kyungsoo from Kai’s lap. He turned her around to settle onto his lap, his mouth coming down to kiss her. Kyungsoo wrapped her arms around Sehun’s neck, pressing herself close as Kai undressed behind them.
He leaned back against the foot of the couch, hand lazily stroking his erection as he watched Sehun and Kyungsoo make out. Sehun’s hands ran down Kyungsoo’s body, grapping the slip and pulling it from her body. They had to break apart so Sehun could pull it down her legs and off her body. He tossed it aside and stared down at Kyungsoo in all her naked glory.
He raised a hand and slowly moved it from Kyungsoo’s neck, over her breasts, past her entrance, and down her legs.
Kyungsoo trembled. With a gentle push, she lay down on the floor, Sehun and Kai hovering over her. Lips were pressed all over her body, a nip here, a lick there.
Sehun took a marked interest in her breasts, tongue coming out to flick over her nipples. Kyungsoo moaned, arching as she pressed Sehun further into her chest. She was so distracted by Sehun’s tongue that she failed to notice that Kai had settled between her legs until she felt a cool puff of air over her wet entrance.
Kyungsoo startled at the first touch of his tongue. Kai pressed an arm across Kyungsoo’s waist to keep her hips in place as he continued to lick her entrance. His tongue found that one point that made her tremble and writhe and he exploited it, tongue working furiously. At some point, his finger had come into play, gently slipping inside. Soon one finger became two and then a third was slowly squeezed into her.
It began as a slow build until it just crashed over her. Kyungsoo let out a gasp as her orgasm hit her.
Kai and Sehun watched the pleasure wash over her face, her body slightly shaking as her orgasm wracked her body.
Kyungsoo opened her eyes, unaware that she had closed them at some point. She gave them a satisfied smile. “That was great but I hope that’s not all…”
“That was only the appetizer.” Kai smirked as his finger gently circled that one point.
Kyungsoo smiled. She lifted a hand and grabbed the boy closest to her for a kiss. Her tongue slipped into Kai’s mouth as her hand ran down his body and gently circled his erection. With a firm grip, she moved her hand up and down.
At this same time, Sehun had settled between her legs and had latched his lips around that one point. He gently sucked, shocking Kyungsoo into gasping, pulling away from Kai to stare down at Sehun. There was a twinkle in his eye as he continued to play with Kyungsoo’s entrance.
Kai frowned. He gently turned Kyungsoo’s head back towards him. Kyungsoo gave a sheepish smile and pulled him down for a kiss, her hand returning to his erection.
Sehun slipped a finger into Kyungsoo’s entrance, feeling how wet and ready she was. He pulled away and wandered off for a moment, returning later with some condoms. He grabbed one, ripping the foil and rolling it down onto his cock. He sat up and gently pushed Kyungsoo’s legs further apart as he lined up to her entrance. Slowly pushing in, Sehun groaned as he felt Kyungsoo’s warm walls hugging his dick.
Kyungsoo gasped, hand stilling as she looked at Sehun holding tight to her waist. She whimpered a bit, feeling so full. With a small nod, Sehun gently pulled back and pushed back in.
Kyungsoo moaned, hands coming to grip at Sehun’s forearms as he slowly fucked her. Kai sat next to them, watching as he stroked his dick.
“K-K-Kai…come here.” Kyungsoo moved her head, looking at Kai.
Kai carefully made his way over. Kyungsoo reached out, running a hand over his dick before leading it to her mouth. Her tongue came out to lick at the tip, gently teasing the slit, before she took more into her mouth.
Kai groaned, hand coming to slip into Kyungsoo’s hair as she licked and sucked. The angle was too awkward for her to bob her head so her hand gently stroked what her mouth couldn’t cover. Kai could feel Kyungsoo’s gasps and moans vibrating down his cock as Sehun continued to gently thrust into her. He caught Sehun’s eye and gently leaned over to kiss him.
Kyungsoo moaned, watching as Sehun and Kai made out above her. Her mouth never stopped as Sehun slowly increased the pace of his thrusts. She pulled off Kai’s cock as she felt her orgasm nearing. “I’m close.”
Sehun pulled away and smiled. He leaned down and gently kissed Kyungsoo. He pulled back and swiped his tongue over her bottom lip, gently nibbling on it. Kai leaned down and kissed Kyungsoo as well before he slipped his dick back into her mouth. Sehun’s grip tightened on her waist as his thrusts increased in speed and force.
Kyungsoo’s hands were balled into fists as her orgasm neared. With a final thrust, she came. Sehun and Kai groaned in unison. Kai pulled out and came over Kyungsoo’s breasts as Sehun spilled in the condom.
Harsh breathing filled the room as the three gazed at one another. With an innocent smile, Kyungsoo swiped a finger through Kai’s cum, gathering some onto her finger and bringing it to her mouth.
Kai felt his cock stir, watching the sight. He saw Sehun’s cock stirring as well. “Ready for another round?”
Kyungsoo smiled. “Yes, but why don’t we switch positions?”
Kyungsoo lay spent, Kai and Sehun curled up next to her. Her chest heaved as she fought to catch her breath after that last round. This had been the sixth time in a week. Ever since she had first slept with them, they’d had sex every week, averaging about four times a week. Some weeks were more and some weeks were less, depending on their schedules. They had gone through many different positions, some Kyungsoo hadn’t even imagined but had been willing to try. She ran a lazy hand through their hair, smiling as they shifted closer but still asleep.
As much as she enjoyed being with both Kai and Sehun, it was just a little too much dick for her taste.
Poor boys will be so sad but maybe she could be convinced to come back…provided they persuaded her the right way.